My The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion: Vol. 1 Book Review - No Spoilers
Plot Summary
The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion: Vol. 1 by Beth Brower brings me into the day-to-day misadventures of Emma M. Lion, a fiercely witty and independent twenty-year-old who arrives in late-Victorian London on March 5th, 1883. After the loss of her parents, I watch Emma set out to claim her inheritance: Lapis Lazuli House in the quirky neighborhood of St. Crispian’s. Except the house isn’t hers just yet—it’s currently shared (awkwardly) with the scheming Cousin Archibald.
I see Emma’s plans for a quiet, academic life constantly disrupted by her oddball relatives (especially Aunt Eugenia), eccentric neighbors, and St. Crispian’s unpredictable rhythm. Through her journal entries, she navigates all the absurdities, small triumphs, and setbacks that make up her world. Volume 1 covers March and April, setting up Emma’s makeshift living situation, her plots to earn income by letting out part of her home, and the parade of offbeat characters. The story moves fast, like the first act of a play, dropping hints of mysteries and relationships that will grow in the books to come.
Why I Love This Book
I love how sharp and funny Emma’s voice is. From the first page, her dry humor and the way she skewers the absurdities around her had me laughing out loud. The format—journal entries—draws me close, letting me share in her joys, doubts, and daily victories. I care about her stubborn drive for independence, how she pushes back against social rules but still loves the oddball people in her life.
The cast is unforgettable: Cousin Archibald is perfectly odious, Aunt Eugenia’s meddling is hilarious, and the neighbors are each their own brand of strange. I enjoy how every minor character adds color, and I love watching Emma try to maintain some dignity while chaos swirls around her.
What sets the book apart is the beautiful balance of wit, vulnerability, and charm. When I finish, I just want to pick up the next volume—there’s something comforting and addictive about Emma’s world. The writing gives me echoes of Austen, Oscar Wilde, and L.M. Montgomery, but with a sly, modern edge.
Who Will Like This Book
If you want a historical novel that’s more about character than plot, you’ll like this. It’s great for fans of witty heroines, clever social commentary, and found family. If you love books that mix humor, introspection, and lots of quirky side characters (think Austen or Montgomery, but with a journal format), this fits right in.
The pace is gentle and sometimes meandering—if you crave high stakes or intense romance, you may want to look elsewhere. But if you’re searching for a comforting, smart, and genuinely funny read that lets you linger in a unique voice, this is absolutely for you.
Tagged As
historical fiction, regency, Victorian London, journal-format, strong heroine, wit & humor, found family, quirky characters, slice of life, coming of age, gentle pace, clean read, female protagonist, indie series, comfort read, slow burn, no romance (in this volume), series starter.
Steam Level
🌶️ | Clean
There is no romance or explicit content in this first volume. The focus stays on Emma’s personal growth, finding her place, and witty observations about the world around her. If you want a book that’s truly clean, lighthearted, and full of warmth, you’ll find it here.
